Skip to main content
We are now open to walk-in customers with or without appointments. Call our office at 800-860-1060.
COVID-19 Resource Page
Coronavirus
About
About Us
Who We Are
Our History
Mission and Core Values
Privacy Policy
Meet Our Team
Blog
Careers
Locations
Newsletters
Resources
GET A QUOTE NOW!
Home/Auto Quote
Commercial Quote
Farm/Agriculture Quote
Group Health Benefits Quote
Individual & Family Health Quote
Client Center
Client Portal
Make a Payment
Refer A Friend
Report Claim
Request Change
Contact Us
Toggle navigation
800.860.1060
Personal Lines
ATV/Boat/RV
Auto
Farm
Home
Personal Umbrella
Commercial & Niche Markets
Business Insurance
empty
Niche Markets
Agribusiness & Farm
Churches
Concessionaires
Lumber & Logging Industry
Medical Malpractice
Non-Profit Organizations
Oil & Gas
Private Schools & Colleges
Pull Protect
Trucking and Transportation
Health & Benefits
Affordable Care Act
Health & Employee Benefits
Individual Health
Medicare
Voluntary Products
Additional Products
Disability Insurance
Life Insurance
Long Term Care
empty
FormFire
Financial Services
Meet Our Team
About
Meet Our Team
Filter by Location
- Any -
Berlin
Mansfield
Newark
Orrville
Shipshewana
Wadsworth
Wooster
Filter by Dept
- Any -
Administrative
Commercial
Health
Personal
Wealth Management
Apply
Brock Hostetler, CIC, TRS, Master Logger
Principal & Business Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Chad Heller, CIC, AFIS®
Personal & Agriculture Operations Manager
330.893.2600
Chris Gertz, RHU®, REBC®, GBA®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Darrick Hummel, CIC, CPRM
Principal & Personal Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
David Coil, CIC, FLMI, Master Logger, PP
Principal & Business Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Evan Hershberger, CIC
Agriculture Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Jock Rottman, CIC, TRS
Business Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Tom Yoder, J.D.
Business Account Executive
330.893.2600
Austin Taylor
Principal and Benefits Operations Manager
330.683.1050
Cheryl Amstutz, LUTCF®
Personal Account Executive
330.683.1050
Deana Alexander, RHU®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Eric McDowell, CIC
Business Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Goldie Yoder, CISR
Personal Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Jason Troyer, CIC, CLCS
Business Account Executive
330.893.2600
Mitch Pertee, CIC, CRM
Business Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Patty Sturgeon, RHU®, REBC®, LUTCF®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Steve Rohrer, CIC
Personal Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Tom Gregory, LUTCF®, RHU®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Tony Rohrer, CIC
Principal & Business Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Phil Teague, CIC, CRM
Business Risk Advisor
330.335.2521
Cheryl Andrews, CIC
Personal Account Executive
330.345.3536
Connie Sutton, CISR
Personal Account Executive
330.345.3536
Matthew Yost, CIC, CRM
Principal & Business Risk Advisor
330.345.3536
Mike Sommers, CLU®, ChFC®, RHU®, REBC®
Principal & Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Vaughn Troyer, CIC
Principal
330.893.2600
Lillian Kauffman, CISR
Bond Specialist
330.893.2600
Lori Wright
Receptionist & QCS
330.893.2600
Benjamin Yoder, AINS
Business Account Executive
330.893.2600
Kara Hanna
Business Account Manager
330.893.2600
Rod Stutzman, RHU®, REBC®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Bev Miller, CISR
Senior Business Account Manager
330.893.2600
Amanda Gerber, RHU®
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Deb Bell, CISR
Personal Account Manager
330.893.2600
Brenda Hershberger
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Tiffany L. Miller
Business Account Manager
330.893.2600
Stephanie Collett
Receptionist
330.683.1050
Tina Balis
Personal Account Manager
330.683.1050
Stephanie Pearson, CISR
Senior Business Account Manager
330.683.1050
Christie Mullet, PHR®
Director of Human Resources
330.893.2600
Carol Bell, CISR
Senior Business Account Manager
330.683.1050
Brittany Armentrout
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
J. Mark Zook, CPCU®, CIC, AU
Business Account Executive
330.345.3536
Mary Beth Wilcox
Personal Account Manager
330.345.3536
Kari Ream, CIC
Senior Business Account Manager
330.345.3536
Ty Raber, CISR
Senior Business Account Manager
330.345.3536
Kelsey Miller
Financial Account Manager
330.893.2600
Julie Piazza, CISR
Senior Business Account Manager
330.335.2521
Jim Burns
Claims Specialist
330.345.3536
Lynn Keaton
Benefits Processing Coordinator
419.522.5158
Alana Clemmer
Senior Business Account Manager
260.768.4547
Regina Yoder
Personal Account Executive
260.768.4547
Josh Keister
Business Risk Advisor
260.768.4547
Cody Mast, CIC
Commercial Operations Manager
330.893.2600
Alexis Cornell
Personal Assistant Account Manager
330.893.2600
Kate Kaufman, CIC, AFIS®
Agriculture Customer Service Specialist
330.893.2600
Sue Turskey
Receptionist
330.683.1050
Janalee Walton
Personal Risk Advisor
330.345.3536
Brock Nettleton
Business Risk Advisor
330.345.3536
Luke Gibson
Business Risk Advisor, Churches and Nonprofits
513.335.3659
Paula Truax
Claims Manager
330.893.2600
Tom Brenner
Business Risk Advisor
330.335.2521
Jordan Yoder
Personal Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Michael Harwood
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Nichole Dalenberg
Benefits Customer Service Specialist
330.683.1050
Mark Lewis, CCLA
Claims Specialist
330.683.1050
Nate Mills, LPCS
Personal Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Chad Olinger
Business Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Cindy Yoder
Accounting
330.683.1050
Kevin Weaver
Accounting and Bonds
330.683.1050
Tracey Trestka
Benefits Customer Service Specialist
330.893.2600
Kelley Wallick
Benefits Customer Service Specialist
330.893.2600
Matt Schlabach
Personal Risk Advisor
330.893.2600
Jolene Taggart
Marketing Coordinator
330.893.2600
Gina McNeill
Business Account Manager
330.335.2521
Holly Drzazynski
Benefits Customer Service Specialist
330.893.2600
Audrey O'Brien
Benefits Account Executive
419.522.5158
Sarah Kitzmiller
Benefits Customer Service Specialist
330.683.1050
Andy Yost
Benefits Risk Advisor
330.683.1050
Jay Bland
Business Account Executive
800.860.1060
Marsha Pifher, AIS™, AINS®, CPIA
Personal Account Executive
330.335.2521
Drew Lanctot
Business Account Manager
260.768.4547
Stephanie Hornbrook
Personal Account Executive
330.683.1050
Sarah Sheely
Business Account Manager
330.893.2600
