Get Personal or Commercial Insurance in Middlebury, IN

We do the insurance shopping for you.

Call (574)825-5458 or click below for a quick quote!





Middlebury Office Contact Info

Physical Address: 13489 County Road 16, Middlebury, IN  46540

Mailing Address:  PO Box 433, Middlebury, IN  46540

Phone Number:  (574) 825-5458  |  Toll Free:  800-860-1060  |  Fax Number:  (260) 768-4651

Office Hours:  Monday - Friday 8:00 am to 5:00 pm

Our Insurance Services in Middlebury and Shipshewana, IN

If you live in Shipshewana, Middlebury, LaGrange, Goshen, Elkhart, or any of the other towns and cities in the LaGrange and Elkhart counties, feel free to stop by our office in Middlebury or Shipshewana to let us help with your insurance needs.  We can provide just about any personal or commercial insurance type you may need, and we also specialize in some niche markets, delivering even more value if you fall into one of those categories.

Insurance for Individuals and Families

Home insurance
Auto insurance
Renters insurance
Condo insurance
Motorcycle, ATV, snowmobile insurance
RV insurance
Boat and watercraft insurance
Classic car insurance
Rental property insurance
Flood insurance/overland water protection
Mobile home insurance
Valuable possessions insurance
Excess liability/umbrella insurance
High net worth insurance
Secondary home insurance
and more!

Insurance for Businesses

Enjoy the Hummel Group Difference

We Shop For You!
As an independent insurance agency, we're not bound to one insurance carrier and will shop around until we find the custom plan that's perfect for you.

Superior Support During a Claim
Unlike most insurance agencies, we have 3 full-time claims managers whose sole job is to make sure our client's claims go as smoothly and as stress-free as possible.

We Pick Up When You Call!
Expect to be connected to your friendly, dedicated account manager within seconds when you call us. No "touch-tone-run-around" or different person every time you call!


We know how frustrating it can be trying to work with unresponsive, slow or preoccupied insurance agents. Not only is it frustrating, but it can also negatively affect your bottom line. That's why we pride ourselves on being responsive and proactive.

When you choose Hummel for your insurance, you gain a partner who simplifies your insurance and ensures you are properly protected.  Our goal is to create a lasting partnership built on trust.

Earning Your Trust Since 1957

Since 1957, Hummel has been building its business on its uncompromising values of integrity, trust & hard work.
When it comes to insurance and risk management, this means that your hummel risk advisor is going to provide you with a custom-tailored plan that's best for you, not our company. We're in the business of trust-building, not selling policies.

Hummel Group is a Trusted Choice Independent Agency. 
To learn more about what this means for you, take a look at the Trusted Choice Pledge of Performance by clicking the Trusted Choice logo.

Claims Service You Can Count On.
If you need to submit a claim, you get one of our full-time claim specialists to advocate for you with the insurance company and support you through the entire process, step-by-step.


Our niche expertise & superior client support delivers a superior experience, better coverage & lower premiums. Get a risk-free quote today!


Technology When You Want It, People When You Don't
  • woman on Hummel mobile website

Take advantage of our online Client Portal and Insurlink mobile app to:

  • access policy information
  • print ID cards
  • request changes
  • report claims
  • and more!

But of course, we are always just a phone call or email away, and are more than happy to help you with anything you need. 


Click here to sign up for a Client Portal and InsurLink login.

We're Your "One-Stop-Shop" - Bundle Our Services & Save!

Take advantage of the discounts provided when you bundle multiple policies, such as home and auto.  Do you need an umbrella policy?  Is your boat covered on your home policy?  Click the links below to learn about our additional services.

Areas We Serve
  • map of Ohio and Indiana locations
    map of Ohio and Indiana locations

Most of our clients reside in Ohio and Indiana, and we have offices within the following cities. So if you're close to one of them, feel free to stop by and say hi!  All of our paperwork and onboarding is done virtually, so being close to an office is not necessary. You'll get a dedicated account rep who will take great care of you either way!

Office Locations:

Outside of Ohio or Indiana?  No problem!  Hummel Group is licensed in many of the lower 48 states.  Give us a call to see how we can help you!

The Next Step is Easy

Call us at (574)825-5458 or send us a message.